Are you paying too much tax?

Calculator, pens and tax paperwork on a desk

This is the question I get asked most often, usually a little apologetically, as though it is a cheeky thing to ask. It isn't.

Most owner-managed companies are not paying wildly too much tax. They are often paying a little more than they needed to, because decisions got made in the order they came up rather than the order that suited them. The van needed replacing, so it was replaced.

Planning is really just looking at the whole picture before you commit rather than after, and there is rarely one right answer, because so much depends on what else you have going on personally.

Salary and dividends, and why the mix matters

You have two ways of taking money out of your own company. A salary is a cost of the business: it comes off profit before corporation tax, so the company gets relief, but it carries income tax and National Insurance – yours and the company's. A dividend comes out of profit already taxed through corporation tax, so there is no deduction, but it carries no National Insurance and is taxed on you at lower rates. You can see how the two currently compare on our tax rates page.

That is why most owner-managers settle on a modest salary topped up with dividends. The right salary protects your National Insurance record, which matters for your state pension, and earns the company a deduction without much employer National Insurance to pay. Where it sits depends on thresholds that move, and on whether your company can claim the allowance that reduces employer National Insurance – a single-director company with no other employee generally cannot. One caution: dividends can only come from profit the company actually has, and must follow shareholdings. Take money it hasn't got and it is a loan to you, not a dividend, with its own tax charge.

Employing a spouse or family member

If your husband, wife or partner genuinely works in the business, paying them for it can be sensible: it moves income to someone who may have unused allowance or spare basic rate band, and the company gets a deduction for work being done anyway. The word carrying the weight is genuinely. The pay must be justifiable for the work actually done, and a generous wage for a role nobody can describe is a deduction waiting to be challenged. Put them on the payroll properly, because employment law and minimum wage rules apply to family members in most situations. Giving a spouse shares so they receive dividends is also well-trodden, but it must be a genuine outright gift of shares carrying full rights, and it only helps if their own tax position has room in it.

When it makes sense to leave profit in the company

There is a quiet assumption that profit should be drawn each year. It shouldn't necessarily. Profit left in the company has been taxed once through corporation tax and stops there until you take it out, so if you don't need the money – or drawing it would push you into a higher band this year when next year looks quieter – leaving it alone is often the cheapest thing you can do. The trade-off is that the money is the company's rather than yours, the personal tax still waits whenever it comes out, and a balance that builds into cash or investments unrelated to the trade can affect the reliefs that depend on the company being a trading business, which matters if you ever sell or wind up.

Pension contributions paid by the company

This is the one most often left on the table. Where the company pays into your pension rather than you paying out of money already drawn, the contribution is normally an allowable cost for the company, with no National Insurance on it and no income tax on you now. The tax comes later, when you draw the pension. The useful quirk is that your own personal contributions are limited by your earnings, which is restrictive if you take a small salary and mostly dividends, while employer contributions are not. They are still capped by the annual allowance, which can be reduced for higher earners – the current limits are on our tax rates page. The downside is access: the money is locked away until pension age.

Company cars

Cars are where good intentions go wrong, and it is worth seeing why. If the company provides a car you can use privately, you are taxed on a benefit built from the car's list price and a percentage driven by its carbon dioxide emissions, with employer National Insurance payable on top. Because the percentage is the lever, a fully electric or very low emission car produces a small benefit while a conventional car produces a large one. That is why nearly every owner who wants a company car looks at electric, and why a conventional one through the company is usually an expensive way to buy a car. Vans get a flat benefit where private use is more than incidental, so a genuine commercial vehicle often stacks up better. The alternative is to own the car yourself and charge the company for business mileage at the approved rates, which sit with the other current figures here.

Capital allowances on equipment and vehicles

When your company buys equipment, tools, computers or commercial vehicles, relief comes through capital allowances rather than as a straight expense, which usually means writing the cost off in full against profit in the year it is incurred. Cars are the exception: they sit outside the up-front allowance and the rate of relief depends on emissions. Relief follows when the cost is incurred, not when you finish paying, so hire purchase doesn't delay the claim. If you lease rather than buy there are no allowances, because you don't own the asset – you deduct the rentals instead.

Timing, and why the year end matters

All of this is a timing question as much as an amount question, and you work to two year ends. The company's year end governs corporation tax; the personal tax year end governs what you pay yourself.

Before the company's year end you can still make a pension contribution or bring forward equipment you were going to buy anyway. Afterwards those doors are shut: you cannot backdate a pension payment or create a dividend retrospectively. Before the personal tax year end you can choose whether a dividend falls this year or next. If your income swings about, splitting dividends across two years can keep you out of a higher band, or away from the point where child benefit is clawed back. Those thresholds are on our tax rates page.

It is mostly a conversation before the year end rather than after, which is why our company accounts and tax work is built around talking while you can still act. What I can't promise is a saving – sometimes you are already doing the sensible thing, and knowing that is worth something too.

Questions worth asking

  • Is my salary and dividend split still right, or was it set years ago and never revisited?

  • Do I need all the money I am drawing this year, or could some of it stay in the company?

  • Would a company pension contribution suit me, given what I take as salary?

  • Before I buy the next vehicle, what does each option cost once the tax is in the picture?

  • When is my year end, and do we talk before it or only afterwards?

This is general guidance rather than advice for your own situation, and the detail is where these decisions are won or lost. If you would like to talk yours through, the first call is free – get in touch.

Get in touch.

The first call or meeting is free, and there's no obligation at the end of it. Tell us what's going on and we'll tell you honestly what we'd do about it.