How business profits are taxed

Two people talking through figures at a meeting table

Once you have settled on a structure, the next question is usually how the profits get taxed – and whether a different structure would leave you better off. The answer depends less on the headline tax rate than people expect, and more on how the money reaches you.

This article covers how profits are taxed as a sole trader, as a partnership and through a private company limited by shares: which tax applies, what you report and why the lowest rate is not automatically the structure that leaves you with the most.

The "a limited company means less tax" myth

There is a long-standing belief, based on tax rates that are now well out of date, that you automatically pay less tax if you trade through a limited company. For a lot of small owner-managed businesses, that is simply not true.

Here is why. A company pays corporation tax on its profits first. Then, when you take that money out as salary or dividends, you pay tax personally on what you have taken. A sole trader pays tax once. A company owner who needs all of the profit to live on pays across two layers.

So yes, the headline corporation tax rate sits below the higher rates of income tax, and you can compare the two – the current figures are on our tax rates page. But a lower rate on the first layer does not mean a lower bill overall once you account for getting the money out. What matters is what you are actually left with, not the rate printed on the company's return.

Sole trader

Which tax. You personally pay income tax and National Insurance contributions on your taxable business profits. There is no separate business tax.

Reporting. You file an annual self assessment tax return with HM Revenue & Customs, reporting your business profits alongside any other personal income – employment, rental, savings and so on.

Timing. Profits are assessed by tax year rather than by your own accounting year, and the return and the payment both fall due some months after that tax year ends. The gap catches people out, because the money has usually been spent by the time the bill lands. The dates sit alongside the rates on our tax rates page.

Partnership

Which tax. The partnership itself pays no tax. Each partner personally pays income tax and National Insurance contributions on their share of the taxable profits.

Reporting. Two layers of reporting rather than two layers of tax. The partnership files a return showing the profits and how they have been split, then each partner files their own self assessment return including their profit share. The deadline follows the self assessment pattern, but the tax is paid individually by each partner.

Private company limited by shares

Which tax. The company pays corporation tax on its taxable profits, including non-trading income such as interest or investment returns. The company is legally separate from you, so if you draw money out you may then pay income tax and National Insurance on a salary, and income tax on dividends. This is where the myth above unravels.

Reporting. The company files a corporation tax return disclosing its profits and any other earnings. Paying yourself a salary also brings you into payroll, with its own reporting every time you run it.

Timing. Corporation tax is payable a set number of months after the end of the accounting period, and the return is not due until some time after the payment – the opposite of the order most people assume.

Where a company genuinely does win

None of this makes a company a bad idea. It means the saving comes from specific circumstances rather than the structure itself. A company can be more efficient when:

  • Profits are significantly higher than the amount you need to draw

  • You do not need to withdraw everything, so profit can be retained to fund growth

  • Earnings can legitimately be split across more than one person, such as a spouse who owns shares and has allowances going unused

Splitting income has limits worth understanding before you rely on it. If the person you are sharing with already pays tax at the higher rates, you are moving the burden around the household rather than reducing it. And paying a family member a salary brings employment law and minimum wage rules with it, so take advice before you set it up.

Count the cost of the structure, not just the tax

Tax comparisons often ignore what a company costs to run. Confirmation statements, statutory accounts, a corporation tax return and payroll filings all take time or money, usually both, and the fees can swallow a modest tax saving whole. That ongoing work is what our company accounts and tax service covers – a real cost of the structure rather than an optional extra. A comparison is also only as good as the figures behind it.

If you move abroad

Moving overseas while running your business makes working out where your profits are taxed much more complicated. Residence is decided by rules that look at your actual circumstances, not by where you consider home to be, and people get this wrong in both directions. If a move is on the cards, get advice before you go.

Questions worth asking

  • How much profit do I actually need to draw to live on, and how much could stay in the business?

  • What would my total bill be as a sole trader compared with a company, counting both layers of tax?

  • What will the extra filings and professional fees cost me each year?

  • Is there anyone else who could legitimately hold shares, or be paid for work they genuinely do?

  • Am I setting enough aside, given the gap between earning profit and paying the tax on it?

  • If my profits change significantly, when should I look at this again?

Your structure should be resilient as well as tax efficient, so weigh up the legal and administrative side first and treat tax as part of the decision rather than all of it. The lowest headline rate does not mean the lowest bill. This is general guidance rather than advice for your own situation, and if you would like to run your numbers properly, the first conversation is free – get in touch.

Get in touch.

The first call or meeting is free, and there's no obligation at the end of it. Tell us what's going on and we'll tell you honestly what we'd do about it.